Download your free report on Content Marketing in the era of AI in partnership with

The CMO’s Next Big Challenge Isn’t AI. It’s Bringing The Board With Them.

There’s never been a more exciting time to be in marketing. But I also wonder whether there’s ever been a more difficult time to demonstrate its value.

We’re operating in a world where customer behaviour is changing at an extraordinary pace. The channels through which people discover, research and choose brands are multiplying, and the journeys between them are becoming increasingly difficult to track.

Yet in many boardrooms, the expectations around marketing measurement haven’t evolved at quite the same speed.

And I think this creates one of the biggest leadership challenges facing CMOs today.

How do we demonstrate the true commercial impact of marketing when increasingly we can’t see the entire customer journey?

We’re measuring a different world with yesterday’s expectations

At Reflect Digital, our quarterly SearchPulse research is giving us a fascinating window into how consumers are changing their search behaviours.

People are moving between traditional search, AI assistants, social platforms, reviews and brand websites as they build confidence in their decisions.

And importantly, they’re not always visiting your website to engage with your brand.

Your content might inform an AI-generated recommendation. Your digital PR might establish the credibility that makes someone shortlist you. Your social presence might reinforce a decision they’ve been considering for weeks.

Then, when they’re ready, they arrive directly on your website and convert.

From an analytics perspective, that journey can look remarkably simple.

From a human behaviour perspective, it’s anything but.

And therein lies the challenge.

Traffic can decline while brand influence grows. Conversions can happen without a clearly attributable journey. Individual channels can appear less effective when viewed in isolation, despite playing an important role in the overall decision.

Of course, we can’t assume every decline is simply a measurement problem. Sometimes performance genuinely needs improving.

But we do need to be careful that we’re not drawing the wrong conclusions from an increasingly incomplete picture.

The danger of overinvesting in measurement

One of the most interesting discussions we had at our recent SearchPulse Brunch & Learn centred on AI visibility tracking.

There’s a growing industry of platforms promising to tell brands how visible they are across AI search.

And there’s absolutely value in understanding how your brand is being represented and recommended.

But I worry we’re in danger of chasing the illusion of perfect measurement.

Unlike traditional search, AI experiences are deeply contextual and increasingly personalised. Two customers can ask the same question and receive different answers based on their preferences, previous conversations and the context available to the assistant.

So, while tracking a set of prompts can provide useful directional insight, it can’t tell us everything.

And the cost of trying to track more and more of those variations can quickly become significant.

For me, this raises an important question for CMOs:

At what point does the investment in measuring performance start to compete with the investment in improving it?

I’d argue that understanding the actual motivations, barriers and decision-making behaviours of your audience is potentially far more valuable than another dashboard showing a percentage of AI visibility.

We need measurement, absolutely. But we also need to be comfortable making informed decisions when the data is imperfect.

That’s always been part of great marketing leadership.

The marketing investment paradox

Here’s another challenge.

As traditional measures become less reliable, the pressure to justify investment can increase.

And yet, the work required to build and maintain brand influence is arguably expanding.

We’re no longer thinking purely about how to rank in search or drive traffic from paid media.

We’re considering how brands appear across AI-generated answers, social conversations, third-party recommendations, editorial coverage, reviews and all the other touchpoints that contribute to consumer confidence.

Traditional search hasn’t disappeared. Far from it.

But we’re adding new dimensions to the strategy, rather than simply replacing old ones.

For CMOs, that presents an uncomfortable paradox.

At precisely the moment when you may need to invest more broadly to protect future growth, the metrics historically used to justify that investment may be becoming less persuasive.

And that’s where I think the conversation needs to change.

Rather than asking which channel generated the conversion, perhaps we need to spend more time understanding which combination of experiences created the confidence to convert.

Rather than simply defending traffic targets, we need to show how brand visibility, trust and consideration are influencing commercial outcomes.

This isn’t about abandoning accountability.

It’s about evolving what good accountability looks like.

The boardroom conversation we need to be having

If there’s one thing I’d encourage CMOs to prioritise right now, it would be educating the wider leadership team.

Not just about AI.

About people.

How are your customers discovering brands differently? What does their decision-making journey now look like? Where are they building trust? And what does that mean for how your organisation should invest?

Because this isn’t simply a marketing measurement problem.

It has implications for financial planning, commercial forecasting, technology investment and ultimately business growth.

And while CMOs may understand these shifts, we can’t assume the same understanding exists across every leadership function.

The CFO may still be looking for the attribution model that definitively proves return. The CEO may be questioning declining website visits. The board may be looking for certainty in an environment where certainty is becoming harder to achieve.

It’s our responsibility as marketing leaders to help them understand why.

But I also think this is an opportunity.

An opportunity to move the conversation beyond channel performance and back towards the fundamentals of customer understanding, brand preference and commercial growth.

An opportunity for CMOs to lead a much broader strategic conversation about how the organisation wins customers in a changing world.

Perhaps we need to get comfortable being a little less certain

For years, digital marketing has benefited from the perception that almost everything can be measured.

And while that data has been incredibly valuable, I wonder whether it’s also made us a little too dependent on having a number to validate every decision.

Now we’re being challenged to combine measurement with research, experimentation, behavioural insight and professional judgement.

That’s not necessarily a backwards step.

In fact, it might help us become better marketers.

Because ultimately, the goal was never to generate the most impressive dashboard.

It was to understand people well enough to influence their decisions and drive sustainable business growth.

In my opinion, this next chapter isn’t about having the most sophisticated tracking technology; the key to success will be connecting changing human behaviour to commercial strategy, and bringing the rest of the board on that journey.

And perhaps that’s where we should be investing more of our time.

I’d be interested to hear how other CMOs are approaching this. Are your board-level conversations about measurement and marketing investment changing fast enough to reflect what’s happening with your customers?

At Reflect Digital, we’re already helping businesses navigate these conversations, and one of the ways we’re doing this is through tailored workshops for senior leadership teams. Focusing on the changes in human behaviour, exploring what they mean for your customers, your marketing strategy and your measurement, and creating a shared understanding across the leadership team. If this is a conversation you’re looking to move forward with within your business, I’d be delighted to explore how we could help.

Column

Thank you for joining
Little Grey Cells Club

You will receive a confirmation email from [email protected] shortly.

If you don’t see this email in your main email inbox, please check your spam folder. If found in your spam folder, we kindly ask that you mark the address as safe (or ‘not spam’) and add our email address to your contacts. Please also forward it to [email protected] to let us know.

We are very committed to the deliverability of our emails and to only provide value (and never spam) for our community.

Welcome to Little Grey Cells Club. We hope to see you at one of our community gatherings soon.